Some differences between Texas Lemon Law and California Lemon Law
Two new car buyers purchased the same year, make, and model vehicle from Chrysler. The main difference between these two buyers is that one purchased their vehicle in Texas, while the other purchased it in California.
Quiz: in the event that both vehicles are defective lemon cars, which consumer is better off and more likely to get a repurchase or replacement?
Answer: the California car owner is more likely to win their lemon law case. Why, you ask?
The reasoning is because each state has its own version of the “lemon law.” The California Lemon Law has provisions that are much more consumer friendly than Texas Lemon Law. As to why California law is better than Texas law?…my suspicion is that car manufacturers have been more successful in effectuating lemon law legislation by utilizing lobbyists and special interest groups in Texas than in California.
Here are some significant differences between Texas and California lemon law:
1) California lemon law has an automatic attorney fee shifting provision that forces the car manufacturer to pay the consumer’s attorney fee if the consumer wins. Texas only allows consumer attorneys to become involved only if the car manufacturer is represented by an attorney first (otherwise, the consumer will have to pay for their own attorney fee).
2) The mileage deduction for a vehicle repurchase or replacement in Texas assumes that the average lifespan of a vehicle is 120,000, which is an extremely heavy deduction against the consumer, as compared to California.
3) California law covers small business vehicles, while Texas law focuses on personal consumer use.
4) Texas has a “30 day” repair presumption similar to California, but the only way the rebuttable presumption is triggered is only if the dealer or manufacturer failed to provide the consumer with a comparable loaner vehicle.
Please note that this is not an exhaustive list. For further comparisons, please contact your state’s lemon law lawyer. For more information about the California Lemon Law, go here.
Read full story
Related posts:
- Texas Lemon Law article in the Lufkin Daily News Jeff Bates, a Texas attorney, wrote an article in the Lufkin Daily News regarding the Texas Lemon Law this past...
- Similarities between Texas Lemon Law and Michigan Lemon Law Renee Walsh, a fellow blogger and attorney, recently wrote a very informative blog article regarding the Michigan Lemon Law and...
- Texas lemon law for wheelchairs As an attorney who frequently handles Texas lemon law cases, I often receive calls from potential clients regarding lemon law...
- Texas lemon law deadline or statute of limitation (SOL) The single most important information that consumers need to know about the Texas lemon law is the deadline to filing...
- California Lemon Law Extended to Military Personnel Transferred to California On January 1, 2008, SB 234 (Corbett) will go into effect. This bill, which California Governor Arnold Schwartzenegger signed on...